Skip to content
Get SocialGet Social
← How To Get Social
At homeFor organisers

How many players do you need for a Traitors-style game?

The short answer: eight players is the comfortable minimum, sixteen to thirty is the sweet spot, and about a quarter of them should be traitors. Plus one host, who doesn't play.

That's the answer we'd give for Treachery!, our own Traitors-style game, and it holds for Mafia, Werewolf and any home version of The Traitors, since they are the same game underneath (we compared them in Treachery! vs Mafia vs Werewolf vs The Traitors). The detail, by size:

Players and traitors, by size

PlayersTraitorsWhat it's like
6 to 71Works, but short. The traitor is usually caught, or wins, within three rounds. Play it twice.
8 to 112The comfortable minimum. About 45 minutes.
12 to 163 to 4Very good at home. Enough people for the traitors to hide.
16 to 304 to 8The sweet spot. Five or six rounds in under an hour, and everyone still gets to speak.
31 to 60SplitOne circle stops working. Play two circles, or two sessions back to back.
60 to 200SplitSeveral circles with a host each, or sessions through the day.

The ratio: about a quarter

Choose roughly a quarter of the players as traitors, and never more than a third. Two for eight, three for twelve, four for sixteen, seven or eight for thirty.

Too few traitors and the first one caught ends the game. Too many and the loyal players never get a vote that sticks. If your group tends to be suspicious and quick, go towards a third; if it's quiet or new to the game, stay near a quarter so the traitors aren't caught by accident in round one.

Why under six doesn't work

With five players and one traitor, every vote is a one-in-four guess and the game is over in two rounds. With five and two traitors, the traitors win almost by arithmetic. If there are only five of you, play something else and save it for when more people arrive.

Why past thirty it stops working

Past about thirty people, one circle stops managing itself. The loud half argues; the quiet half drops out and checks their phones, and a vote takes as long as a round should. The fix isn't a bigger circle. It's more circles of 20 to 30, each with its own host, or the same circle played twice. We've written up how in a Traitors-style game for a large group. At Camp Wildfire, where we have run it every summer since 2024, festival sessions have taken up to 200 at a time that way.

"It was interactive, super engaging, and the perfect way to connect with other festival-goers."

Tom, a Camp Wildfire player

How long it takes, by size

At home with eight to twelve, a game is about 45 minutes, and you'll play it twice. With thirty, a round is eight to ten minutes and five or six rounds fits into under an hour, provided the host keeps the clock. The days and the votes are what take the time, so the bigger the group, the more the host has to cut the debate short.

Don't forget the host

Whatever the headcount, add one person who doesn't play. They run the nights, announce the murders, call the votes and keep the tone. A player who hosts as well either knows too much or enjoys it too little. There's a word-for-word host's script in how to run a Traitors-style game, and the full rules are in how to play a Traitors-style game in an hour.

Want us to host it instead?