How to run a Traitors-style game: a script for the host
The rules of a Traitors-style game fit on a postcard. What makes the night good or flat is the host: what they say, when they say it, and how fast. This is a script for the host, line by line, that you can read from a phone or a card the first time and drop by the second. It's the one we'd hand a friend running Treachery!, our own version; the rules behind it are in how to play a Traitors-style game in an hour.
Before anyone arrives
- Count the roles. About a quarter of the players are traitors, never more than a third: two for eight, four for sixteen, seven or eight for thirty. How many players you need has the table.
- Make the slips. One per player, folded, each saying TRAITOR or LOYAL. Shuffle them in a hat or a bowl.
- Keep your own list. As you hand out the slips, note who is a traitor. You'll need it, and you'll forget otherwise.
- Set the chairs in a circle with nothing in the middle. Everyone needs to see everyone's face.
- Something to track who's out. A whiteboard, a big sheet of paper, or names you cross off where everyone can see.
The opening
Stand where everyone can see you, wait for quiet, and go slowly:
"Welcome. Among you are traitors. They know who they are. They know who each other are. Nobody else does. Every night, the traitors will murder one of you. Every day, you'll argue, accuse, and vote to execute someone you think is a traitor. If you catch every traitor, the loyal win. If you call for peace while a traitor is still among you, the traitors win. One rule above all: if anyone asks you directly whether you're a traitor, and you are, you lie."
Then hand out the slips: "Look at your slip. Don't react. Fold it up and put it away."
Night
Lower your voice. This is the bit that sets the tone.
"Night falls. Everyone, close your eyes."
Wait until every eye is shut. Look round the circle; if someone is peeking, say "I can see someone's eyes" without saying whose.
"Traitors, open your eyes. Look at each other. Choose your victim, silently. Point."
Watch the traitors agree. If they disagree, nod at the person most of them are pointing to.
"Traitors, close your eyes."
Wait a few seconds so nobody can tell where the rustle came from.
Morning
"Morning comes. Everyone, open your eyes. Last night, someone was murdered."
Pause longer than feels comfortable.
"It was… Sam."
Say the name last, after the pause. In our version the first person murdered comes back as the Leader, with the deciding vote in a tie, so the first murder is a promotion: "Sam, you're not out. You're the Leader. In a tie, your vote decides."
Day
"You have five minutes. Talk to the person next to you first: who seemed too pleased this morning?"
Then widen it: pairs into groups of four or five, then one spokesperson per group says who they suspect and why. Your job in the day:
- Bring in the quiet ones. "Priya, you've been very calm. Why?"
- Repeat accusations so everyone hears them. "So Tom thinks it's Jo, because she laughed at the murder."
- Keep the clock. Give a one-minute warning, then stop it. A day that drags kills the game faster than any traitor.
The vote
"It's time to decide. Peace, or execution? If you choose peace and a traitor is still among you, the traitors win."
If they choose execution:
"On the count of three, point at the person you want to execute. One, two, three."
Count the fingers aloud. The person with the most is out, and gets a parting shot: "Before you go, you have one last accusation." Then: "Reveal your slip." Let the room react. Cross the name off where everyone can see. Back to night.
The end
When the last traitor is executed:
"That was the last traitor. The loyal have won."
Or, if peace is called while a traitor remains, ask the traitors to stand: "Traitors, reveal yourselves." That moment is why everyone plays. Give it a beat before anyone talks.
What the host does between the lines
"I was really impressed with people staying in Character and not breaking out and chatting. I think that is down to the host…"
A test player at one of our 2020 games
That test player was talking about a different game of ours, and it's the same job. The host holds the frame, so the players can lose themselves in it. A few habits that do it:
- Never play. You know who the traitors are. Even a raised eyebrow gives it away.
- Be dramatic, and kind. The tone should be serious enough to matter and silly enough that everyone is still friends at the bar. Nobody is a liar in real life for being good at this.
- Run a tight clock. With thirty people a round of eight to ten minutes keeps the whole game under an hour. Cut the day short before it goes flat.
- Know your twists. For a second game, add one: traitors may recruit a loyal player instead of murdering, a seer sees one traitor at night, or you announce a murder and reveal nobody died. One twist a game is plenty.
The home and office versions differ only in the setting: at home with friends, at work in a lunch hour, or with the family at Christmas.